Honest Comparison
Tithe.ly vs Sendifai
Tithe.ly is primarily a giving platform with church management features. Here's how we honestly compare.
Feature Comparison
Feature
Sendifai
Tithe.ly
Free CRM plan
Contact management
Family/household linking
Groups management
Online giving
Giving app
Text-to-give
Check-in system
Coming Soon
Church website builder
Email campaigns
SMS messaging
AI assistant
AI content writer
Pastoral care tools
UK-based / GDPR-first
Gift Aid (HMRC)
Direct Debit (GoCardless)
AI giving intelligence
Free giving tier
Pricing Comparison
Sendifai
- Free CRM: Unlimited contacts, smart segments, AI assistant — always free
- Free Member Portal: Self-service hub for members — always free
- Add-ons: Email Marketing, Messaging, Community, Giving, Ticketing, Runsheet, Media Hub, Guest Management, Spaces — each starts free and scales smoothly with your usage
- Charities: 30% off subscriptions with approved charity status
Tithe.ly
- Giving: Free (2.9% + $0.30 per transaction)
- ChMS: $49-149/month
- Sites: $19-49/month
- All-in-one: $149-249/month
Where Tithe.ly Wins
Best-in-class online giving with low transaction fees
Free giving platform (just transaction fees)
Text-to-give functionality
Church website builder included
All-in-one platform with giving at the centre
Strong mobile giving app
Where Sendifai Wins
Free CRM forever (not just giving)
AI assistant and content writer for communications
Dedicated pastoral care tools
UK-based with GDPR-first design
Lower CRM pricing for contact management
Email marketing with AI optimisation
Consider Using Both
Tithe.ly excels at giving. Sendifai excels at CRM and communication. Many churches use a dedicated giving platform alongside their CRM.